What rules governed the selection of public office holders? Athens may have had a democracy, but that didn't save the, from corruption. After all, it only lasted 300 years. On the other hand, they were polar opposites in many aspects, from social spheres, political structures, to military might, which I believe there are some hidden depths in these city-states. Sparta had different enemies. Option 1 : Based on research consider the ethical rationale, I choose option 1 it's a discussion. They had the krypteria who would go out and murder the helots. There are many reasons why Sparta is more superior to Athens. They were also taught how to take care of themselves and not depend on other people to do their work for them. In the blank, insert the most appropriate word. I think no because there are way more weaknesses than strengths. Moreover, education was vital to the Spartans. In document D it states,The boys of Sparta were lashed with whips at the altar of Artemis Orthia, frequently to the. The Ancient Greeks renowned use of democracy influenced Ancient Romes government structure. On the one hand, the two poleis share certain obvious affinities, such as language, geographical scope, a common Greek ancestry etc. For instance, Their whole lives were about military training even after 30 the Spartan boys were required to serve the military until they were 60 (Document 2). At the age of seven, boys were taken from their parents and sent to live in the military barracks. Lastly, Sparta had a far, Spartans valued military power. Athens and Sparta are both well-developed societies, however, Sparta stands out as the superior polis because Spartan women have more rights, education was distributed equally among boys and girls in Sparta, and Sparta had a strong and united culture. The Spartans devoted all their time to the military, partaking in military training, hunting and war battles. For instance, Their whole lives were about military training even after 30 the Spartan boys were required to serve the military until they were 60 (Document 2). At this age, the boys were sent to the agoge. A problem one might suggest is that the Spartans were only taught the basic skills of reading and writing. Moreover, education was vital to the Spartans. They both share similarities towards their cultural background but had different views in creating an ideal society in addition to their states place in the world. It would also teach them music, reading, writing, philosophy, and, Spartas women were known for their promiscuity and boldness . There were many cases of bribery in the government that wasn't taken seriously by the court. Athens and Sparta, located between the Aegean and the Ionian Sea, allied with each other in the Greco-Persian war. Moreover, they differ from the concepts of a well trained or educated society and a well built military, but share similarities in their government format. If you were born unhealthy you would of been left outside the city to die. The strong belief in Gods and oracles in Ancient Greek shaped the religion of Ancient Romans. Aside from this, that is about the only thing Sparta had going for them. Permitted to own and inherit land, Spartan women had more power in the household than what was common for women elsewhere in Greece, and they could even supervise large estates. A Spartan father had to present his child to the elders of the tribe, if deemed fit enough, he was allowed to live. The belief was that this would help the Spartan children would be better accustomed to the heat and cold. Athens may have had a democracy, but that didn't save the, from corruption. Weaknesses include blind spots, poorly developed skills, or problematic personal behaviors. This would happen if you lived in Sparta. According to Document D, The Spartans learned to read and write for purely practical reasons: but all other forms of education they banned from the country, If an man wasnt interested in fighting and wanted a strong education, he was simply out of luck since in Sparta, killing others was more important than schooling. Spartas weaknesses definitely outweighed its strengths. The Spartas were first located in southern Greece called the Peloponnese. % The Romans conquered many territories and took on their cultures as well, in particular the Ancient Greek culture. 3 0 obj Sparta, not so much, they just wanted strong jocks. When you are asked about your strengths and weaknesses in an interview, it is not enough to simply say, "I have good people skills.". However, as Plutarch notes, this lack of freedom to live by ones whims is not a lack of excellence, but rather a more pure and base form of excellence. Though they were both city-states in Greece they had their differences. A problem one might suggest is that the, Spartans were only taught the basic skills of reading and writing. Strengths include knowledge, attributes, skills, and talents. Sparta needs to balance their military and education better. When. The Spartas were first located in southern Greece called the Peloponnese. Ancient Greek civilizations played a major role in the history and development of the Ancient Rome civilization. They had a pretty good social structure as well with full citizens at the top, noncitizen in the middle, and slaves at the bottom. If youve heard of Sparta and think its fantastic, think again. In Athens slave were not citizens they were property. Sparta was very violent and all they thought about was having the strongest military. The army was incredible, they even beat Athens in the Peloponnesian War. There are many reasons why Sparta is more superior to Athens. They both share similarities towards their cultural background but had different views in creating an ideal society in addition to their states place in the world. In school both boys and girls would learn reading, writing, mathematics, basic-combat, and self-defense. The oligarchy structure in Sparta enabled it to keep war as a top priority. Education in Sparta: Did the Strengths Outweigh the Weaknesses? Though Spartan women were not serving the military, they still were educated and got to have more status and freedom, and rights than the rest of the Greek women. Sparta government was ruled by two kings and three Ephors, and a Council of Elders this government was called oligarchy meaning its ruled by a small group. All of these experiences are educational, but since the Spartans were not allowed to learn about these they had done themselves a disservice. If the child was male, the child was taken away from his parents at the astonishing age of seven to be controlled and trained by the government's agoge. It was the strengths of these two societies that brought the ancient world to its heights in art, culture and with the defeat of the Persians, warfare. Chloe had three tests on the same day. My opinion strengths did not outweighed the weakness of sparta education and I will explain how the strength was the most important than caring the weakness of sparta education. To begin with Sparta would abuse the children. Although their main job is still child-bearing, this job held much more honor and respect because in theory, a Spartan women gave birth to strong, Spartan boys who would in turn become strong and successful soldiers for Spartas renowned military . Life in sparta was different than athens because sparta had no interest in art,music and education. Though the two cities shared several traits such as slavery and gradation systeming, they were separated by their political and economic differences. The weaknesses of Spartan education outweigh the strengths because the training was harsh, children were encouraged to steal, and many subjects were not taught. If deemed fit enough, the boy would remain with his family until he was 7 years old. Document C A Spartan father had to present his child to the elders of the tribe, if deemed fit enough, he was allowed to live. In Sparta power was given to citizens through the assembly which consisted of all male citizens in Sparta, but in theory anyone could participate. First, try to identify patterns or themes among your areas of strength. Its time we get an answer! This can help you zoom in on what you're really good at. Document B states, Lycurgus required them to harden their feet by going without shoes. This rule caused a lot of pain for little culmination. Our argument is that in Spartan education the weaknesses outweigh the strengths. It takes 14 long and exhausting years to complete the training in order to become a soldier. The strengths of the Spartans education outweighed, the weaknesses but there were some problems. Sparta was very violent and all they thought about was having the strongest military. Even Athenian philosophers like Plato and Socrates praised this education system. Although their priority relied on military and combat over anything else, in many ways intelligence and knowledge were also important to succeed in war. To begin with, Athens and Sparta were both famous in antiquity for their legend, cultures and the character of the people. The men in Sparta had no choice of their future. They lived a frugal lifestyle and without any luxuries. This would happen if you lived in Sparta. city-state of Sparta was infamous for many things. In document D it states, The boys of Sparta were lashed with whips during the entire day at the altar of Artemis Orthia, frequently to the point of death, and they bravely endured this, cheerful and proud, vying with one another. Spartans would also leave the babies out to die if they thought the newborns were weak. During the training process they would have them constantly making the phalanx and having other soldiers trying to break. The Flagellation is a competition that is held yearly, where young Spartans get whipped repeatedly. <>>> This statement from the document shows that Sparta takes. Finally, the citizen boys entered a military training camp for two years, until the age of twenty. This person is a unique one, a part of the society, living his life and has future plans and of course glad that he was felt worth and given a chance to be. To quote, but only free, native born males (p. 29). Sparta government was ruled by two kings and three Ephors, and a Council of Elders this government was called oligarchy meaning its ruled by a small group. Hence, lets look at how did their people obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community, and who held public office first. Spartans were not allowed to travel to travel abroad, so "they should have nothing to do with foreign ways and undisciplined modes of living.". Sparta not only had persia as an enemy on the outside, but Sparta also had the helots. Spartan fathers were forced to bring they kids to inspection. The Constitution of Sparta by Xenophon states, Instead of softening the boys feet with sandals, [Lycurgus] required them to harden their feet by going without shoes. Also, instead of letting them be pampered in the mater of clothing, he introduced the custom of wearing one garment throughout the year As well as, he required such moderate amount of it (food) that the boys would know what it was to go with their hunger unsatisfied (Xenophon Constitution of Sparta ) These quotes prove that the boys experienced and were taught that they couldnt always live in luxury that sometimes all you need is the bare necessities. The education of Sparta varied in strengths and in weaknesses. G%qg'! A gem of the Archaic and Classical Greek Era that we have come to discover. Sparta's weaknesses definitely outweighed its strengths. To better understand your weaknesses, start by making a list of: Sometimes it can be hard to think of all the areas of strength we actually have. My opinion strengths did not outweighed the weakness of sparta education and I will explain how the strength was the most important than caring the weakness of sparta education. To begin with, Sparta would abuse the children. Sparta had the strongest army of their time with only having a population of 25,000 and an army of 8,000 men. Another quote from the article states, Only the rudiments [basics] of reading and writing were taught; instruction consisted for the most part in obedience, bodily fitness, and courage to conquer in battle. (J.T. They were also given the option to by there freedom by raising money through their work. After the victory, Athens gained wealth and dominance over the other Greek societies causing tensions between Sparta. While, Sparta is a town near the river, located in the center of the Peloponnese in southern Greece. According to Document A, an important magistrate was appointed to take charge of the agogee. There are tons of strengths. Everything was centered in sparta was focused on the military. Like many early Geek settlements, Sparta had to fight to survive. Therefore, regarding the education in Sparta, the weaknesses outweighed the strength because the Spartan's didn't value family morals, the basics of reading and writing were taught, and the upbringing of Spartan boys was cruel and painful. (who was much bigger than Sparta) as enemies on the inside. Hence, lets look at how did their people obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community, and who held public office first. Therefore, regarding the education in Sparta, the weaknesses outweighed the strength because the Spartans didnt value family morals, the basics of reading and writing were taught, and the upbringing of Spartan boys was cruel and painful. Spartan boys were introduced to the custom of wearing one large garment throughout the year, as opposed to wearing normal clothes. This statement from the document shows that Sparta takes, Sparta, as a society, was abusive to children. Sparta's weaknesses outweigh their strengths because they are educated under a harsh, rigorous discipline, the boys are ripped away from their families without a choice, and because only practical reading and writing were taught; all other education was banned. For example, maybe you're a natural coach. Yes, strength did outweigh their weakness because them being well structured to having the utmost of military power and also including their own emphasis on teamwork/ 731 Words 3 Pages Decent Essays Dbq Spartan Education They were forced to sneak into helot territory with a dagger and a lot of food and secretly capture and kill some helots (Doc C). In Athens slave were not citizens they were property. Sons of nobles went to high school for four more years of learning about the sciences and the arts and politics and government. (Doc B) Due to the fact that Athens taught women basic domestic skills this allowed men to focus on the advancement of the economic climate, such as trade on the Aegean Sea because they didnt need to worry about their homes. Therefore, regarding the education in Sparta, the weaknesses outweighed the strength because the Spartans didnt value family morals, the basics of reading and writing were taught, and the upbringing of Spartan boys was cruel and painful. Over and over, the Bible gives examples of God's strength manifesting when His people are . Do you want to be abandoned because you weren 't strong and healthy baby? So here's a giant list of strengths to help you identify yours. The education of Sparta varied in strengths and in weaknesses. Therefore, regarding the education in Sparta, the weaknesses outweighed the strength because the Spartans didnt value family morals, the basics of reading and writing were taught, and the upbringing of Spartan boys was cruel and painful. When they reached the age of twenty, they were placed in the, These were all older men who had great wealth. How were two city-states similar in their governmental structures and how did they differ with each other? The strengths outweighed the weaknesses in the education of Sparta because it made women stronger and healthier, the education reduced helots which kept Sparta safe, and it made 547 Words 3 Pages Decent Essays Advantages And Disadvantages Of Being In Sparta Imagine being in Sparta. At the age of seven, boys were taken from their parents and sent to live in the military barracks. The best answer for strength and weakness questions is honest, insightful, and detailed. This statement from the document shows that Sparta takes, During this process they would have hours upon hours of training and they also taught them to feel no pain by whipping them with a whip while they were tied up against a pole, and if they were to wine or cry they would be whipped more. The strong belief in Gods and oracles in Ancient Greek shaped the religion of Ancient Romans. {z=:s cwxF(zz- 0UY-#*_C` j_h +e#~_7 65jvl.";+iQZs(,K)h |%FmU!PsrAp V[PQp9y(|BA CX5nmPij o4QDvpYa6j]cI8s, v1:F3du|dmw[kuh(1l!^.gExtf(eHF<6Zzvud\~v,e5Y',az 9:>jQGYgR:3TIpPu0VXdnagcWsWk5+7 SbUztz!,sZ(mrH+Vmh}a{4G. The Spartan-like training and leadership style of Ancient Greek war heroes formed the, In comparison to other states of ancient Greece, Spartans were less cultured, due to their nominal interest in material possession. There are lots of reasons why we should explore our strengths and weaknesses. Ancient Greek civilizations played a major role in the history and development of the Ancient Rome civilization. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. If you have already discussed your own profession in the class. literature. On the one hand, the two poleis share certain obvious affinities, such as language, geographical scope, a common Greek ancestry etc. It would also teach them music, reading, writing, philosophy, and, At around six or seven years old, young boys would be taken from their homes to be trained as Spartan warriors. xZYo8~n3` XHr2_*HX%xogX;W"+%"o8X~UG~\/ykE*Z/ = &?2??^J3?Z&}D2:?fDU8_]v&'k5N\$s\%~^c"z0r-OZ*__B StoryboardThat is a trademark of Clever Prototypes, LLC, and Registered in U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Sparta also had an assembly just like Athens, but the main decisions were taken by the Council of Elders with two kings and twenty-eight other men as its members. When they reached the age of twenty, they were placed in the, and that is to conceive a boy that will become a Spartan. In this colony, the Spartas only vision was bloodthirsty war and violence. Ancient Greece is a land consisting of many city-states, called poleis. At the age of seven, boys were taken from their parents and sent to live in the military barracks. Athens, a democratic and well invested political city found apprehension with their neighboring municipality Sparta, a highly dense military society. Who held public office? One reason the strengths of Spartan education did outweigh the weaknesses was because boys in the agoge have been trained, Imagine that you are a boy in Sparta. Thats a weakness. Although they were most known for how good they With Athens and Sparta fighting for power and territory, it brought about the Peloponnesian wars that lasted thirty years, leaving the two city-states in their own shadows. It was located on a peninsula called the Peloponnese. Here's a huge. The Spartans were basically the soldiers of the Ancient Greek city-state, Sparta. The Ephors, a group of officials, decided on criminal cases with the council of elders . It increases self-awareness. It doesnt have to be anything big. Despite this lack of respect for human life, Sparta had atoned, Sparta is considered by many people as the greatest and most powerful city in Greece for its great strength and power among the other city-states on the Peloponnese peninsula. In this colony, the Spartas only vision was bloodthirsty war and violence. Education in Sparta: Did the Strengths Outweigh the Weaknesses? Throughout this paper, what will be discussed is: the author credentials, the books main aim, the books evidence, and the author writing style of the book. The krypteia would be sent out, and during the day, they would hide out in obscure places, and during the night, they would hunt and kill the strongest helots. The baby even if in the very early stages of lifetime, has a right to life, a purpose and a future, and should not be punished. Thus, females were encouraged to do physical activity and get physically fit. Transcribed Image Text: Thnity Cains 4.5.22 Education in Sparta: , Did the Strengths Outweigh the Weaknesses? Hence, lets look at how did their people obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community, and who held public office first.